Category: Sports

FootballSportsTop Articles

KELLY AN UNINSPIRING CHOICE FOR WESTMEATH HOTSEAT

 

Colm Kelly has been appointed Westmeath manager for the 2018 season with the Louth native taking over from Tom Cribbin.

I thought it was a positive move when Cribbin resigned, but my thoughts changed dramatically when I saw the caliber of candidates lined up to replace him. It’s a sad state of affairs when Kelly and former Wicklow manager Johnny McGee are seen as the best options available, especially when some of the names originally touted for the job were Anthony Cunningham, Luke Dempsey and Pete McGrath.

It was also a shame no local candidates were in the running, with Jack Cooney, John Keane and Dempsey all quality managers. Kelly did a reasonably good job with Louth, winning back to back promotions but that wasn’t good enough for Pat Flanagan to keep his job, as he got the Lake County from Division 3 to Division 1 and was just a whisker away from eliminating Jack O’Connor’s Kerry from the championship in 2012.

Flanagan can feel he was treated very unfairly as can Tom Cribbin following back to back Leinster finals. His record in Leinster was outstanding, as no team other than Dublin defeated Westmeath in his 3 years in charge.

We can compare Kelly and Cribbin’s record across a 3 year period from 2015 to 2017, with both managers in charge of Louth and Westmeath respectively during that time. In Kelly’s first year in charge they were demoted from Division 3 to Division 4, and lost to Westmeath in the Leinster championship before losing to Tipperary by 23 points in the qualifiers. Westmeath were relegated from Division 2 but they regrouped to beat Louth, Wexford and Meath for the first time ever in the championship, before losing to Dublin and Fermanagh.

In 2016 Westmeath were relegated to Division 4 of the League, whilst Kelly had success with Louth in getting promotion from the bottom division, but again it was Cribbin’s Westmeath who did better in the championship, overcoming Offaly and Kildare before losing to Dublin again and narrowly to Mayo, with both sides later competing in the All-Ireland final. Louth on the other hand, overcame Carlow, but went on to lose against Meath and Derry.

In 2017 both sides gained promotion, from Division 3 and Division 4 respectively, but again Westmeath would go on to have a better championship, beating local rivals Offaly. They then were hammered by Dublin, before being narrowly overcome by Armagh in the qualifiers. Louth, on the other hand, overcame Wicklow, before losing to Meath and then Longford in Drogheda. That Longford defeat was a massive setback for Louth, and Kelly resigned soon afterwards.

These comparison’s show that there was very little between the two managers, with Cribbin’s record in the championship far superior to the Clogherhead native. Louth had defeated Westmeath in the championship in 2014 prior to Cribbin’s takeover but they have lost numerous players since so it’s hard to determine what level they are at.

I wish Colin Kelly all the best as Westmeath manager in 2018 and have no doubt he is a good manager, but is he any better than some of the Westmeath based managers? I don’t think so. It’s with regret that I see John Keane has stepped down as under 21 manager as he has had a fantastic season with the group along, with his backroom team of Fergal Wilson, Garry Connaughton and  Eamon Gallagher.

Kelly is set to take charge of both the senior and under 21 sides for 2018 and with the likes of John Heslin in the team, supplemented with footballers such as Ger Egan, Kieran Martin and John Connellan, there’s definitely potential there. Hopefully Kelly will get the best out of the team and Westmeath will reach another Leinster final, after being drawn on the opposite side of the draw to Dublin. If we can maintain our Division 3 status, win the Leinster quarter final and put up a good Leinster semi-final performance, followed up with a good qualifier display, it will have been a relatively positive campaign.

There is enough potential in the squad for that to happen but is Kelly the right man to unleash it? We’ll have to wait and see.

Conor McKenna

Super 8s Podcast
08Nov
SportsSuper8s Podcast

“Con O’Callaghan keep your nose out” Sean Óg O’Hailpín

  Young footballer of the year Con O’Callaghan talent is endless and last Sunday his small ball talents were on show with and excellent display for Cuala in their 7 point win over Kilkenny...

08Nov
SportsSuper8s Podcast

Super 8’s Podcast Episode 2 with CPA Chairman Micheál Briody

  This week on our Super8s Podcast we are joined by Micheál Briody Chairman of the CPA for a very important chat about the release of the 2018 Master Fixture list and what it means for club players....

07Nov
FootballMark TownsendSportsTop Articles

WHY DIDN’T STEPHEN CLUXTON GET AN ALL-STAR?

Picking the football and hurling All-Star teams is a hazardous business. Sitting down to select the Sunday Game team of the year the likes of Joe Brolly, Colm Cooper and co did a half decent job, but the...

06Nov
Ladies GAASports

What a 2017 Camogie All-Star Team would look like without Cork and Kilkenny.. Ger Kinane

  The 2017 Liberty Insurance Camogie All-Stars took place in the Citywest Hotel on Saturday night. As expected Cork dominated the team taking 8 places while runners up Kilkenny received 4 All-Stars....

06Nov
FootballHurlingMark TownsendSportsTop Articles

ARE INTER COUNTY PLAYERS BEING PUSHED TOO HARD?

  When Darach Honan was a young man he seemed to have the hurling world at his fingertips. Blessed with inordinate physical stature, as well as no little hurling prowess, he towered over everyone on...

nick riewoldt
03Nov
SportsSuper8s Podcast

Nick Riewoldt “One of the most incredible Athletes I’ve ever come across” Ray Connellan

  St Kilda’s rookie Ray Connellan gives us a insight into club legend Nick Riewoldt, for anybody that doesn’t know who the man in question is take a look at the clip below and you will...

02Nov
FootballHurlingMark TownsendSportsTop Articles

GAA BOOKS OF THE YEAR PREVIEW

As you may have noticed (and I made sure to wait until after Halloween ended to post this) Christmas is coming, and with that in mind, all of the GAA households across the country will be looking for a...

01Nov
InterviewsSportsSuper8s Podcast

Super 8s Podcast Episode 1 with AFL star Ray Connellan

  Sportstalk.ie are thrilled to have their men’s podcast up and running after months of planning, we hope to bring you stories from around the GAA world and have a relaxed chat with the top...

31Oct
FootballSports

Heslin stars as St Loman’s chalk up 3 in row in Westmeath

  St. Loman’s Mullingar were deserving eight point winners over Tyrrellspass in Sunday’s Westmeath Senior Championship Football Final, defeating the tidy town on a scoreline of 3-13 to 0-14, to...

Tomedia.ie